CONNECTING YOU TO CUMBERLAND COUNTY NEWS & ENTERTAINMENT. WEEKLY.

25 Best Places to Preorder Your Thanksgiving Feast in Fayetteville and Cumberland Valley

Thanksgiving is just around the corner, and the thought of a delicious feast with family and friends, of course, excites us all.

But thinking about the grocery shopping for endless ingredients, hours spent cooking, and that mountain of dishes waiting afterward.

It’s enough to make you tired before the celebration even begins!

This year, why not take the pressure off and let someone else handle all the hard work so you can relax and fully enjoy the holiday?

With so many amazing options for preordered Thanksgiving meals, you can focus on what matters—enjoying the day with loved ones.

In Fayetteville, many local places and popular chains are offering Thanksgiving meals to suit all tastes and group sizes.

1. Dab’s Soul Food Cafe

Got a big crowd? No worries at all; Dab’s can handle it.

Their meals range from $207 (feeds 4) to $832.50 (feeds up to 30 people).

Their menu is packed with favorites like turkey wings, roast turkey, meatloaf, and pork chops, as well as sides like mac and cheese, collard greens, sweet potato pies, and cornbread dressing.

Orders are open from Nov. 11 to 23, and pickup is available until 2 p.m. on Nov. 27.

Call 910-882-9723 or visit them at 412 N. Bragg Blvd., Spring Lake.

2. Big Erv BBQ & 910 Sweets

Big Erv BBQ is what we call pure, hearty barbecue goodness.

They’re serving up smoked turkey (whole or sliced), chopped smoked turkey barbecue, brisket, ribs, and mac and cheese.

Don’t forget dessert—banana pudding and sheet cakes are on the menu too!

Preorder by texting or calling 910-703-2230 before Nov. 23.

Visit their Facebook page for more details.

3. The Fried Turkey Sandwich Shop

Known for its perfectly fried turkey, this local favorite offers it by the pound for $19, with stuffing at $26 per pan and cranberry sauce at $4 per pint.

Their iconic sweet potato squares are available as pies for $12.

Place orders by Nov. 26 for Thanksgiving Day pickup at either 2318 Paintersmill Drive or 1820 Owen Drive, Fayetteville.

4. Barbara Ann’s Southern Fried Chicken

If you want real Southern comfort food, Barbara Ann’s has you covered with barbecue turkey, fried chicken, mac and cheese, collard greens, candied yams, green beans, cornbread dressing, potato salad, and banana pudding.

As you can tell, they’ve nailed the holiday classics!

Make sure to get your order in by Nov. 21 at 5 p.m.

You can call 910-491-5859 or email [email protected].

Find them at 3740 S. Main St., Hope Mills, or check them out on Facebook.

5. Fresh Market

Are you hosting a smaller, intimate Thanksgiving?

If that’s the case, Fresh Market offers takeout meals, plus turkey and ham à la carte options.

Get your orders in by Nov. 25 at thefreshmarket.com.

They’re located at 230 Glensford Drive, Fayetteville.

6. Carlie C’s IGA

This local grocery chain is a hot spot for Thanksgiving dinners—and they tend to sell out fast!

They have three meal packages:

  • $61.99: Roasted turkey or ham with cornbread dressing and gravy.
  • $79.99: Turkey or ham with candied yams, green beans, cornbread dressing, a dozen yeast rolls, and gravy.
  • $104.99: Includes all the sides with both turkey and ham.

Cakes and pies are available, too!

Visit locations in Fayetteville, Hope Mills, or Stedman, and order by Saturday at carliecs.com.

7. Golden Corral

This buffet chain has Fayetteville roots and offers takeout holiday meals for six to eight people.

Their turkey or ham meal costs $129.99, and pork roast costs $159.99.

It includes mashed potatoes, gravy, stuffing, cranberry sauce, green beans, mac and cheese, a dozen yeast rolls, and a pie.

Order at least 72 hours ahead at goldencorral.com.

Pickup is at 1806 Skibo Road, Fayetteville.

8. Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant

Want to break from tradition? Then switch it up and go Italian with their family meal for $65, which includes lasagna or baked ziti, a salad, bread, and pumpkin pie.

Sweet potato biscuits and other pies are also available for preorder.

Call 910-779-0622 or visit gustonapoletano.com by Nov. 21 for pickup on Nov. 26 or 27.

They’re located at 2711 Raeford Road, Fayetteville.

9. The Honey Baked Ham Company

Classic holiday flavors are what you’ll find here, with honey-glazed ham, turkey, and heat-and-serve sides like roasted broccoli and mac and cheese.

Meals serving up to eight start at $125.

Preorder online at honeybaked.com by Nov. 26, or visit them at 160 N. McPherson Church Road, Fayetteville.

10. K&W Cafeteria

If you’re looking for a traditional Thanksgiving meal without the fuss, K&W Cafeteria is probably your best bet.

For $82.99, you get sliced turkey or ham with potato salad, dinner rolls, cranberry sauce, and three sides of your choice.

This meal is the classics done right, and you won’t be disappointed in the slightest.

Learn more or place your order at kwcafeterias.com.

Pickup is available at 1758 Owen Drive, Fayetteville.

11. Mac’s Speed Shop

Barbecue meets Thanksgiving with Mac’s Speed Shop’s mouthwatering menu.

They’re serving up smoked turkey, brisket, gravy, and three sides for $185, perfect for feeding up to eight people.

Order at least 48 hours in advance for pickup by Nov. 27.

Check out the full details at preorder.macspeedshop.com.

Swing by their Fayetteville location at 482 N. McPherson Church Road to grab your meal.

12. Metro Diner

Metro Diner is keeping Thanksgiving stress-free with heat-and-serve turkey and ham dinners.

Whether it’s a meal for one, four, or eight, they’ve covered you with turkey, mashed potatoes and gravy, green beans, cornbread stuffing, mac and cheese, cranberry sauce, and dinner rolls.

Order online by Nov. 26 and pick up until 2 p.m. Thanksgiving Day.

Visit metrodiner.com or stop by their location at 2132 Skibo Road, Fayetteville.

13. Publix

Publix has heat-and-serve holiday dinners in two sizes: one for up to 8 people and another for up to 15 people.

Both include Butterball turkey, dressing, mashed potatoes, gravy, cranberry orange relish, and a special dessert called marshmallow delight, made with pineapple, cherries, and coconut.

Preorder 48 hours in advance at publix.com or call 910-321-0114.

Pickup is at 3114 Raeford Road, Fayetteville.

14. Smokey Bones

If you’re planning a hearty Thanksgiving feast, Smokey Bones has you covered with a full meal for $129.99, serving up to eight people.

Their meal includes a 12-14 lb turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, green bean casserole, mashed potatoes, gravy, and cornbread with pecan butter.

Preorder by Nov. 27, with pickup available on Thanksgiving Day from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.

Visit smokeybones.com to secure your meal, or head to 1891 Skibo Road, Fayetteville.

15. Popeyes

Are you looking for something bold and different? Popeyes’ Cajun-style turkey is back!

Their pre-cooked turkeys are hand-rubbed with Louisiana-style seasonings for that zesty, signature flavor.

Pick one up for $54.99 or have it delivered for $99 (shipping included).

These turkeys weigh between 11-13 lbs and serve 8-12 people.

Pair it with sides like mac and cheese, Cajun mashed potatoes, or their famous biscuits.

Preorder now at popeyes.com.

For those in Cumberland Valley, options include dining out at Thanksgiving buffets or preordering family meals:

16. Allenberry

Why stress over the stove when you can dine like royalty at Allenberry’s Thanksgiving buffet?

From perfectly roasted turkey to rich, comforting sides, they’ve got all your holiday favorites waiting for you.

Choose between two seating times: 11 a.m. or 1:30 p.m. on Nov. 28.

Allenberry’s team of expert chefs promises a spread that will have you coming back for seconds (or thirds—we won’t judge).

Make your reservation early, as this is a popular pick for Thanksgiving Day.

17. Hershey Lodge & The Hotel Hershey

Let’s talk luxury—because that’s exactly what you’re getting at Hershey Lodge or The Hotel Hershey.

Their Thanksgiving buffets are nothing short of indulgent, with carved turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, and all the extras you could hope for.

And let’s not forget dessert—hello, chocolate treats in Hershey!

Prices start at $76 per adult, and seating times fill up quickly, so grab your phone and call 717-520-5489 to snag your spot.

18. Cassell’s Grille

Cassell’s Grille is bringing Thanksgiving classics to their buffet table, and you’re invited.

Think roast turkey, baked ham, mashed potatoes, and stuffing, all ready to warm your heart and belly.

They’re open for their holiday feast from 11:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. on Nov. 28.

It’s perfect for those who love tradition without the kitchen chaos.

Call ahead to secure your seat—you don’t want to miss this.

19. Oak Grove Farms

If you’re more of a “host at home” type, Oak Grove Farms has your back with fresh, locally sourced turkeys for just $3.39 per pound.

And because no Thanksgiving table is complete without pie, they’ve got plenty to choose from, too.

Preorder your turkey or desserts by November 23, and you’ll be ready for a cozy, farm-fresh feast.

20. Redd’s Smoked Turkey Meals

Redd’s Smoked Turkey Meals are the way to go for a smoky twist on the holiday classic.

They offer two sizes:

  • Half-size meal: Serves 7–10 people for $69.99, including a half-smoked turkey, stuffing, and gravy.
  • Full-size meal: Serves 15–20 people, perfect for larger gatherings.

And if you want more sides, you can add two for just $30.

Preorder by Nov. 24, and let Redd’s handle the hard part while you take all the credit!

21. Talking Breads

Bread lovers, this one’s for you!

Talking Breads has an impressive lineup of freshly baked goods to level up your Thanksgiving table.

Choose from sourdough, ciabatta, Norwegian brown bread, French baguettes, and more.

They also have seasonal favorites like pumpkin rolls to round out your meal.

Place your order by Nov. 24—and don’t wait too long because these goodies are the real deal.

22. Dutch Country Store

Pies and pumpkin rolls? Yes, please!

The Dutch Country Store offers pies for just $10 and pumpkin rolls for $8, making them a budget-friendly addition to your holiday feast.

Pie flavors include classics like pecan, blueberry, and peach.

Call 717-477-9339 or stop by the store to lock in your order by Nov. 25.

23. Paulus Farm Market

If you want to keep it local, Paulus Farm Market is a fantastic choice.

They offer locally raised turkeys for $3.15 per pound and heat-and-eat meals that make Thanksgiving prep a breeze.

You can also preorder Thanksgiving pies.

Pickup is available on Nov. 27, just in time to get everything on the table.

Stop by the market or give them a call to secure your order.

24. T.J. Rockwell’s

For a ready-to-serve family meal, T.J. Rockwell’s has you covered with Thanksgiving takeout packages starting at $95 for a meal that serves 4-5 people.

Are you hosting a bigger group? If so, upgrade to their larger meal option for $180.

Be sure to place your order by November 25, with pickup available on November 26 or 27.

Call their Mechanicsburg location or stop by to reserve your feast.

25. Official BBQ

If you’re craving barbecue flavors for your holiday, Official BBQ is here to bring the heat.

Their Thanksgiving meal packages start at $84.99, including two pounds of sliced turkey, stuffing, giblet gravy, garlic green beans, and six dinner rolls.

Plus, you can add large portions for just $10.99 each.

Preorder your meal and let Official BBQ add some smoky goodness to your Thanksgiving celebration.

There you have it!

Skip the stress, enjoy more time with your loved ones, and let them handle the cooking this year.

Don’t wait too long to place your orders, as these popular spots will sell out fast.

Enjoy a Thanksgiving filled with great food, good company, and lasting memories!